Can Journalism Survive Without Journalists?

When all the journalists are gone who will tell us what we need to know?

When all the journalists are gone who will tell us what we need to know?

Last summer I sat in a ballroom in Chicago along with a roomful of other Black journalists celebrating the induction of Les Payne to the National Association of Black Journalists (NABJ)  Hall of Fame.

Last week, Les Payne was let go with little notice  and less ceremony by New York Newsday.

Scan the NABJ website and you will not find a word that one of it’s founding fathers and past presidents has joined the ranks of  other journalists being shown the door by newsrooms across America.

The only thing that troubles me more than a icon of journalism like  Payne discarded like a old newspaper is the roaring silence from the organization he once led and helped create.   I can’t decide whether NABJ has no idea how to address the dire situation of Black journalists losing jobs left and right or its only purpose is to collect membership dues and provide nothing in return.

My personal take is NABJ has always been much better at begging for more newspaper diversity and totally inept at coming up finding a big stick when the carrots fail.  But what do I know?  Some people think I’m a bit of a militant. 

Payne was named in 2008 to NABJ’s Hall of Fame.  It’s a shock, a shame and a sin that the organization he founded seems more inclined to honor his past achievements rather than assist him in a uncertain future.

When a journalist loses his job it’s not more important than anyone else.  But when an autoworker or waitress loses their job, cars will still be made and food will be served.  When journalists, and particularly journalists of the caliber of a Payne or Nat Hentoff lose their jobs, we lose people who will tell us the truth.

Hentoff was a writer, critic and columnist for the Village Voice for 50 years (!), but this year he was axed from the alternative weekly.  Hentoff wrote in his last column

Around the country, a lot of reporters are being excessed, and print newspapers may soon become collectors’ items. But over the years, my advice to new and aspiring reporters is to remember what Tom Wicker, a first-class professional spelunker, then at The New York Times, said in a tribute to Izzy Stone: “He never lost his sense of rage.”

Neither have I. See you somewhere else. Finally, I’m grateful for the comments on the phone and the Web. It’s like hearing my obituaries while I’m still here.

Hentoff joins the ranks of the unemployed journalists.

Hentoff joins the ranks of the unemployed journalists.

When we run out of people telling the truth who is left to tell it?

Young journalists like NPR’s Farai Chideya loses her show, News and Notes and her job.  Old lions like Payne and Hentoff are dumped because  they’re too old, too expensive or too much part of the past and there’s no place for them in the future, whatever future there is for print journalism.

Every so often I think journalism is going to go the way of VHS tape and vinyl records and I find myself struggling for a rationalization for future journalists to stick with in instead of getting an honest job in a profession that actually may be here in another ten years.


One thought on “Can Journalism Survive Without Journalists?

Don't Be Shy...Leave A Comment.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s